Everyone assumes that bishop's daughter Emily Ebersol will marry a faithful Amish man. But her childhood sweetheart, Luke Lambright, fell in love with racing cars during rumspringa and left Wells Landing. Emily prays for his return, but begins spending time with Elam Rhiel. Elam is certain he'd be the loyal, steady husband Emily deserves. Then, just as she begins to fall for him, Luke returns and complicates Emily's feelings.